My rating: 3 of 5 stars
2.5 stars
Romance book talk mainly, all genres reviews (Sept. - Oct. horror pops up more), and recipes
Captain Hayden St. John stood beneath the overhanging eaves of the ugly Parramatta prison block and watched the matron and a male guard drag the woman toward him through the teeming rain.
Chapters 16 - End discussion (spoilers in updates)....
If only they did not have wives and children to share in the punishment for their wrongs.
*********
“I know. Only I expected to feel grand and righteous, doing so. I had no thought of all its feeling so mixed-up and awful.”
James Russell finally makes his appearance and I actually enjoy how the author makes him seem ineffectual and doesn't ascribe to him a domineering presence. Along with Martha we learn that he's married and has two sons. Moral dilemma time with Martha feeling bad about disinheriting the sons and actually liking his wife.
Mrs. Weaver nodded once as her husband, beside her, put a coarse knuckly hand over hers.
****************
“I’ll put it plainer still.” Mrs. Weaver lifted a gaze that could give a man nightmares. Her voice shook with sentiments too dark to have names. “If you stay in this country I’ll stick a knife in your foul throat. Though I go to the gallows for it and leave my children orphans, I promise you I will.”
Did I mention how much I want a Weaver novella? I WANT A WEAVER NOVELLA.
Martha comes up with the idea to bring everyone together to lay it out for James Russell and tell him that if he does inherit they will make life miserable for him and Mrs. Weaver puts it out there even more. This scene of them inviting James in and them all sitting at the table ready to confront him really worked to make my eyes water, mostly because of Mr. and Mrs. Weaver but gah, the support and determination in this scene. But, yeah, WEAVER NOVELLA.
Such tricky business, being a husband. Knowing when to be your wife’s champion, and when to stand back that she might be her own. So many large and small skills to master beyond simply pleasing a woman in bed. Yet one more unexpected lesson from his time in Sussex.
Wonderfully said. This is where I think this book excelled, it gave me the depth and emotion, not just the sex. The sex was actually probably where this turned out to be the weakest.
After the confrontation scene and knowing James had sons, I knew where this was going to head and I almost was yelling out for Martha to hurry up and come to the conclusion. Theo gets a good grown-up and stand-up to daddy scene with some lovely supporting from sister. It's a bit of a quiet ending but this story was definitely all show and not tell and I greatly enjoyed that.
Chapters 8-11 discussion (Spoilers in updates)..........
So, I think I was right with there being something to the Mr. Atkins angle, this starts off with Martha alluding/talking about how, a sort of shady version of him, was the star of her fantasies but now Theo is replacing him and that makes her panic. Fantasizing about the local curate, naughty girl!
The pig came jogging from behind the house, clearly scenting opportunity.
I make no guarantees that this pig doesn't show up as a Romancies Favorite Secondary character nominee.
“Don’t berate yourself so. I don’t want to hear it. You were mistaken in what you expected, and now you know better. We learn that way, don’t we?
This is said by Theo to Martha and what a conversation we could have on how Theo, and a lot of us, give so much love and understanding to others but never that same leeway to ourselves.
Her smile went through him like a fever-chill. What a strange, strange thing, to give a woman such pleasure without touching her.
I'm one of those reviewers that has put "too much sex" in their reviews before and I know some take this as prudishness but what I'm also saying is that the couple didn't have enough emotional depth outside the bedroom. Especially in historicals, I'm showing up for the delicious mental and emotional banter and foreplay. I love how this line gives us some heat through mentally developed emotional heat.
How did one go about saying these things gently? “You’re not a bad man, Mirkwood. I do think you have promise. But while I find I can be cordial with a man who lives for pleasure, and even come to feel a certain regard for him, I cannot, in the end, truly admire such a man. And I don’t care to give myself up to a man I don’t admire. Pardon my frankness.”
Yeeeouch! Martha hasn't learned the old 'honesty without tact is cruelty'. Martha's not purposefully cold and rude, she just never learned better, kind of like Theo isn't purposefully ignorant and spoiled. See what the author did there? Similarities between characters that can create bonding and areas for them to make the other better.
It could have been worse. He didn’t beat you. He wasn’t cruel. That stern self-reproach never did have the bracing effect one would wish.
We get more on Martha's coldness, specifically towards Theo in the bedroom, her husband had a drinking problem and it lead to him forcing himself on her and then not remembering the next day. Martha was thawing towards Theo but then tasted alcohol on his breath and this caused her to grow frigid again. But they talk about it and through that conversation she cracks open even more than before. Building blocks for character growth!
I would say this was probably the, for lack of a better word, slowest group of chapters. We finally learn that Theo is 26yrs old; such young characters for how mature they and the story feels. We also get Martha learning that Mrs. Weaver is pregnant and mentally making a note and vaguely planning out in her mind if she bought the baby if it was a boy to pass off as her own. It's methodical and cold, at the same time in line with Martha and sort of not as she's learned some emotional intelligence. I don't know, she's at the core a very analytical person, so maybe it does fit.
Theo's spending the night now, they're talking more and their sex is getting better and less insert slot A into slot B. There's only 40% left and still feels like a good amount of work needs to be done between these two, curious what is going to happen!
Chapters 5-7 discussion (spoilers in updates)..........
If he wasn’t a man who knew how to please women, then what was he at all?
Theo really has an issue with feeling unworthy and useless and in a way that is no fault to his own, born privileged, and in a way that is his fault, choosing ignorance. It's interesting how our characters are going through their own separate journeys, sometimes helping each other, other times figuring it out on their own.
He’d come here with honorable intentions, and indeed, he could feel the first sparks of anger struck within him—but they were promptly smothered by thick, poisonous shame. What man could stand under Mrs. Weaver’s awful gaze and not suspect a monster lurked deep inside him after all?
Oh this scene. Theo's went back to the house that Christine, the intellectually disabled girl I mentioned in my last update and brought gifts. Her mother Mrs. Weaver sees them close together and obviously thinks Theo is trying to seduce her with gifts. Theo's angry and disgusted, at the situation and himself and I know we're probably supposed to feel bad for him but I was all about Mrs. Weaver in this scene. She breathes the fire at him in a way that she doesn't have to say a word, he owns the estate her family lives on, but Theo knows he's not getting pass this warrior to take advantage of her daughter. The guts, because of consequences, the love, and the bravery showcased by Mrs. Weaver here, just LOVE.
“Also, I suppose I was afraid of appearing ridiculous.” A few at a time, she got the words out, her voice awkward even to her own ears.
These chapters have Martha starting to make an attempt at some form of affection when Theo comes over for the daily try to make a baby. It's starting off mechanical as there are not emotions behind her actions, yet, but she's learning.
“Who was there to love you, then?”
A pretty devastating line to ask someone and you can tell it hits a mark in Martha. We learn that she was pretty much wholly raised by her governess. Martha never learned tender feelings and this why she doesn't know or understand them.
How to word this constructively? She frowned at the far wall. “I consider you rather fortunate to be under his tutelage.” No reproach. Only suggestion
This may seem like an innocuous line in their conversation but I love how it gives us thoughtfulness and intention behind lines, which as our characters' thoughts, gives depth of character.
in hopes she’d look at him as a woman looked at a man who knew all the best ways to surprise her.
I just love this line and the sentiment behind it, imagining that beaming look directed towards someone you love.
Chapters 2-4 discussion (Spoilers in my updates)......
“I can get you funds, Mr. Mirkwood, in exchange for something from you. I need to conceive a child.”
Well, then. Like I said in my previous update, I like how she's open and honest with him. We get a better look at Theo here, too. He's being, for all intents and purposes, babysat by a Mr. Granville who is supposed to teach him estate running and some responsibility. At first I thought I would have liked a London scene with his father showing the conversation but now I think I like this slower lead-in to Theo.
Honey-colored hair, just on that border between blonde and brunette. The kind of hair that went luminous under sunlight, but kept its secrets indoors.
Some of that gorgeous writing I was talking about and gah, I could talk about this line and description all day.
We learn that Martha was only married for 10 months and that she agreed to the marriage because her father was dying, her mother died in childbirth, and she didn't want to be a dependent of her brother, call back to beginning and strengthens her "mutinous" attitude.
They were conspiring against him, the virtuous people of the world. Plainly they did not want him among their number. Well, who was he to battle on when such might was arrayed on the opposing side? Between respectable Mrs. Russell bribing him into her bed, and worthy Mr. Granville all but ordering him back there, what could he do but succumb?
*********
One goose approached, stretched out its neck, and hissed at him, a distinctly triumphant look on its face.
There's little dashes of humor in this that I'm really enjoying, Theo and Granville's cross-talk about cottages, Granville saying he should spend more time with Martha because she is so respectable and Theo could learn some estate running while Theo is thinking about the real reason he is going over to see Martha. I also found myself giving an actual laugh out loud when Theo and Granville were visiting his renters and the pig was trying to get in. I'm notorious for never laughing at books that people find hilarious, but that scene made my weird funny bone tick.
How much of this nonsense would she be obliged to endure?
The sex scenes are emotionally rough because of how distant and mechanical Martha forces them to be and Theo flirting, trying to get to know Martha and warm her up but then giving up and just giving her what he wants. Making it through them requires you to keep in mind the bigger picture and how we're starting at ground zero in their emotional journey.
“The precipitating incident, if you would know, was my expenditure of two months’ allowance to buy a single snuffbox. Sèvres.”
**********
“You see my ignorance. But at least I have some idea of what a gentleman ought and oughtn’t to stand for, and it plain strikes me as a shabby way of doing things. Doesn’t it strike you?” On these last words, he raised his head to face her again, eyes lit with earnest appeal. He could not have said anything more right; anything more exquisitely tailored to win her sympathy, her support, her better regard.
Theo is clearly ignorant of his privilege but the juxtaposition of him saying, talking about the snuff box and then his thoughts during and after the visit to his renters, shows a man starting and willing to think and make a change, which I love reading. Characters that grow and don't start off perfect are always more of a personal favorite. I'm only in the first four chapters, but I'm happy Theo is already starting this journey, it gives him dimensions and makes me more interested in him because he can improve. I also like some of the economical threads woven in, the ideals and period placing it provides.
Of course no girl in this cottage was likely to attend balls, but the simpleminded daughter might have to remain here always, watching her younger sisters grow past her to contrive their own establishments.
These chapters managed to not only get a laugh out of me but also some watery eyes. This observation, thought, and feeling from Theo hit hard. I feel like a lot of the time the compassion and empathy is directed to the family of an intellectually disabled member, instead of the person themselves. Usually, the hero or heroine is caring for them and it's always, "How noble of you!". The last of this little thought feeling was just, watery eyes.