Better Than Friends by Jill Shalvis
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
2.7 stars
I received this book for free, this does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review
She'd gotten really good at leaving over the years.
Seventh in the Sunrise Cove series, each book is set in the small-town but can be easily read as standalones, Better Than Friends was a story about childhood friends who came close to being highschool sweethearts but an accident and emotional angst kept them apart for fourteen years. Olive came to live with her Gram in Sunrise Cove when she was fourteen, escaping not present parents who lived off-the-grid and were too much of free spirits for responsibility. She instantly bonded with Katie, a girl (a character who seems to present on the Autism spectrum) who was an outcast. Katie's twin brother Noah, popular good-looking guy who had an easier social time, became their protector, and Olive's crush.
“Have you ever wondered what it'd be like between us now, as adults?”
Olive's been away from Sunrise Cove for over a decade after leaving right after highschool graduation, but keeping in contact with Katie and sporadically visiting. She's started her own PR company in London but when Katie's husband Joe ends up in a coma after being injured on the job, she answers Katie's request for her to come back and help her get through it. Noah, who was also injured in the same accident as Joe, they both work for the Investigative Services Branch for the National Park Service, is off-duty while he heals and helping out at his sister's too. They've been careful to avoid each other over the years and readers feel the tension right away when they come face-to-face.
He'd not trusted himself to push for a real conversation and reveal feelings he'd long ago buried.
As we get to know the characters, it's both explicitly said, Olive somehow ended up running Noah over Senior year and damaging his leg enough that his baseball career was over before it even begun, and alluded to that there are other issues keeping these two apart. The story provides flashback scenes throughout the book that give us a look at these two in highschool and the events that have lead them to where they are today, which I thought helped give good context. As we get to know them, it's obvious that they both really like each other but Noah keeps saying he doesn't want to be tied down, which is given some foundation because of how he always he had to be perfect and take care of Katie because of pressure from his parents and how navigating society norms aren't as easy for Katie. Olive's stems from the background with her parents, not trusting love and hearing what Noah is saying and something that is alluded to happening between her and Noah five years ago. Once we got into the latter second half, I don't know, the two characters kept acting and saying things in ways that I started to get confused about what was really keeping them apart and it started to feel like the author, not the characters, was telling me they just couldn't be together, if that makes any sense.
She didn't like regrets, but the truth was, she had plenty.
The synopsis talked about some mystery, Olive hasn't been able to get in contact with her parents for a while, they missed their check-in call, and she starts to get really worried. It starts off a vague worry that finally comes into play but the utter and total non-climatic way it eventually got dealt with, well, it didn't need to be in the synopsis making me think there was some action mystery here. The storyline does work to deliver a storm and one bed scenario, so I guess.
Secretly, she loved the fact that there was a side of him that was for her only, not shared with any of the outside world.
This had a good set of characters that were nicely rounded out, three dimensional secondary characters but it kind of caused the romance to suffer a little, I think. The element keeping our two apart, felt pretty weak and it ended up making the ending feel dragged out for me. Still, Shalvis' writing is always smooth and if you're looking for a more sedate story that will occasionally ping with chemistry, take a visit to Sunrise Cove.
