Holiday Ever After: One Snowy Night/Holiday Wishes/Mistletoe in Paradise by Jill ShalvisMy rating: 3 of 5 stars
I received this book for free, this does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review
I love to read a snowy holiday book in the summer!
Three short stories that fit into Shalvis' Heartbreaker Bay series, which I've read four books in (close enough!) were short, varying degrees of enjoyment, quick hits.
One Snowy Night 3 stars
Fate or Karma or whatever was in charge of such things was a cruel master, having her first crush of all people, the one guy on the entire planet who made her feel like that young, neglected, bullied, unwanted teen all over again, be the only smart ride home tonight.
Not for the “Just Talk About It!” crowd. A misunderstanding event that happened between our two leads, Rory and Max, in high-school, had Max angry at Rory and Rory avoiding going home for years. She finally makes a promise to herself that she'll make it home for Christmas but a snow storm leaves her stranded on the highway. Fortunately for us readers, Max is also headed home and we're off with some forced proximity.
Rory crushed on Max in high-school, so those feelings flare up and while Max feels betrayed by her from the high-school incident he also has the feels for her. We get some hotel play and misunderstanding resolving but the I love yous arrived too fast for any deep emotional hit.
Bonus: Carl the doberman
Holiday Wishes 2.5 stars
>They’d tutored each other, the perennial bad boy and the perennial good girl, and then one night they’d been each other’s world in the back of her dad’s pickup on the bluffs of Marin Headlands.
Charlotte has just lost her dad to cancer and she's about to close the Inn she runs down for two weeks and escape to Cabo. Unfortunately for her, she's about to get snowed in with a wedding party, a wedding party who includes her high-school love Sean. They'd slept together and Charlotte had told him she loved him but Sean had just lost his parents, added in with Charlotte was moving, Sean decides to cut the chord and not respond to her calls or letters. Now, years, later, Charlotte's acting like she doesn't know him and Sean is ready to admit to feelings he should have years ago.
I didn't quite feel their connection, a lot hinges on the reader believing that they had a deep, close relationship when they were in high-school and that building block never held the weight for me. Charlotte is coming off her own canceled wedding, with Sean deep in the whirlwind of his brother's and that made me think they were getting swept up into the moment.
Mistletoe in Paradise 2.5 stars
When he opened his eyes and whispered her name, she lost herself in him, completely. Just as when she was with him like this, she also felt . . . found.
Wrapping up our second-chance romances, this had more emotional turmoil for our leads, Hannah and James, to work through. Hannah's charter boat step-dad hosts her mom's bestfriend family that had two sons every year. Just as Hannah and James are old enough to realize their romantic feelings, James' brother dies and shatters both their worlds. James asks Hannah to travel the world with him but Hannah needs stability at that time and they don't speak for years. It's when Hannah is pushed by her mom to deliver divorce papers to her step-dad and James' parents are delayed that they're forced to finally spend alone time together on the charter and talk out their feelings.
Definitely had the emotional grief meat in this one, the brother death and then Hannah dealing with how she feels her step-dad's love is conditional, both those weighty things edged out the romance to me. I'm not sure I believed in their hashing out, making their romance feel a little bereft to me.
View all my reviews

